Skip to content
setlys
All posts

Did the AI change your product? A fidelity checklist for AI photos

Small changes are the ones that slip through: a letter, a shade, a missing strap. Check every AI photo against the real product before it goes live.

By Luis Hernández · ·

In this post
A straw bag with a red stripe in a real photo, and the same bag up close in a café scene.

Did the AI change your product?

Sometimes, yes, and often in small ways that are easy to miss: a logo redrawn, label text turned into nonsense, a color a shade off, a strap that moved. The only reliable check is to put the AI photo next to a real photo of the product and compare them part by part before you publish.

Why it matters more than how the scene looks

A buyer forgives a plain background. They don't forgive receiving something different from the photo. Marketplaces say the same: Etsy doesn't allow editing to "edit an item's appearance" or images that "create false expectations about what the buyer will receive" (Etsy Help), and Google Merchant Center asks for "an unobstructed, clean view of the item for sale" (Google Merchant Center Help).

A beautiful scene with the wrong product is a return, a bad review or a listing problem. Fidelity comes first.

What AI tends to change

An image model can redraw the product along with the scene. When it does, these are the usual places where it shows:

  • Text: brand names, ingredients, sizes and small print come back misspelled or invented.
  • Logos: right shape, wrong proportions, or a letter missing.
  • Color: a slightly different red or a warmer white, especially under a strong scene light.
  • Count and parts: one button fewer, an extra stitch line, a kit with five pieces instead of six.
  • Shape and scale: a bottle that got slimmer, a mug that looks twice its size next to a hand.
  • Materials: matte turned glossy, metal turned plastic, a transparent glass turned opaque.
  • Details buyers look for: zippers, seams, clasps, the pattern of a fabric, the texture of a surface.

The fidelity checklist

Open the AI photo and a real photo of the product side by side, at the same zoom. Then go through this list:

  • Read every word on the product, letter by letter, against the real one.
  • Check the logo: shape, proportions, position and color.
  • Compare the main color on a neutral screen, not only on your phone.
  • Count the parts: buttons, pieces of a set, holes, straps, stones.
  • Check the proportions: height against width, and size against anything else in the scene, like a hand or a table.
  • Look at the material: shine, transparency, texture.
  • Zoom in on the edges, where the product meets the background. Melted or blurry edges are a sign the product was redrawn.
  • Check what's in the scene but not in the box. A prop can look like it's included: if it isn't sold with the product, make it obvious.
  • Look at the thumbnail size too. Some changes only show when the image is small.

How to make the check easier

  • Start from a real photo of the product. A phone photo in good light works, and it's the reference you'll compare against.
  • Keep one approved photo per product as the standard, and compare every new scene with it.
  • Check one product per scene. The more products in a scene, the more chances for one of them to change.
  • If one detail is wrong, don't publish it hoping nobody notices. Make another scene.

How Setlys handles fidelity

In Setlys the product stays the real one. You add a real photo of your product, and Setlys builds the scene around it with AI without retouching or changing the product.

Each scene goes through an automated review that compares it with the real product, and then you can mark the photo as faithful once you've checked it. The automated review helps, but it doesn't replace your eyes: the checklist above is still the last word, and the confirmation is yours.

Setlys also remembers your approved scenes, so the next photo starts from one you already checked. If you start from a cut-out, remove background works on your own photo, so what you get is still your product.

The same check applies to people and backgrounds

If a model wears or holds your product, check the product on them with the same list. And if you want the same model across your catalog, here's how to keep them consistent. On Etsy, remember that AI photos can't be the only ones: the one-unedited-photo rule asks for at least one real photo of the item.

If you sell through Google Merchant Center, there's one more rule, about labels rather than fidelity: Google asks that every image created with generative AI carry metadata that says so, such as the IPTC DigitalSourceType tag TrainedAlgorithmicMedia, and that you don't strip that metadata when a tool already added it (Google Merchant Center Help). It's a different rule from Amazon's label for AI-created people, which the post on keeping the same model explains. Setlys downloads don't write that metadata today: if you upload them to Merchant Center, adding it with a metadata editor before you upload is up to you.

Shoot it anywhere. We'll remove the background.

Your product on its own, background gone, as a transparent PNG ready for your store or social media. Free.

Remove the background

Sources